Apple’s recently released iOS 4 provides enhanced “data protection”, but there is very little on the web now that explains what this really means. In this post I clarify what data protection is and what some of its limitations are.
What Data Protection IsThe release of the iPhone 3GS (and later iPod Touch 3rd Generation) brought hardware-based full disk encryption (FDE) to the iPhone. This was designed to accomplish one thing: instantaneous remote wipe. While the iPhone 3G had to overwrite every bit in flash memory (sometimes taking several hours), disk wiping on the 3GS worked by simply erasing the 256-bit AES key used to encrypt the data.
Unfortunately, disk encryption on the iPhone did little beyond enabling remote wipe. Mobile forensicator Jonathan Zdziarski found that the iPhone OS automatically decrypts data when a request for data is made, effectively making the encryption worthless for protecting data.
So I was curious to learn what encryption improvements were made in iOS 4. Apple calls its new encryption scheme “data protection”, a substantial improvement in security design. Data protection has the primary advantage of using the user’s passcode or password to derive a key that is used to encrypt data on the device. When the phone is locked or turned off, the key is immediately erased, making data secured on the device inaccessible.
Limitations of Data ProtectionThe details of how data protection works are described in Apple’s recently released videos from its world-wide developers conference (see Session 209 “Securing Application Data”). This information is protected by an NDA, but I’ll summarize at a high level five basic limitations.
First, to make data encryption work a user must have an iPhone 4, iPhone 3GS, or iPod Touch 3rd Gen (previous iPhones don’t support hardware encryption). Importantly, 3GS users who upgrade to iOS must restore the device as the iOS 3 file system doesn’t support the new data protection scheme. The steps to do this are described here.
Second, files are encrypted individually by software classes that implement data protection. This means that developers must deliberately choose to use data encryption in their apps, otherwise data is unprotected. Currently, Apple says that so far only Mail is setup to use data encryption, although they say they will eventually bring data encryption to other applications. This means that even with data encryption enabled, text messages, contacts, photos, web history—in short, everything else—is left unprotected.
Third, a user must use a passcode or password. The strength of the password is up to the user, which is generally a good thing for forensicators.
Fourth, to mitigate the threat of a brute force attack, the file encryption requires a key generated by the device itself, in addition to the key derived from the user’s password. This slows brute forcing because the encryption key generation process is slow by design: the iPhone 4 takes about 50 milliseconds to derive the key once the user submits a password. This means an attacker can guess only about 20 passwords per second.
This might not sound like much of a speed reduction, but this actually compares well with software-based encryption products. By comparison, I’ve used AccessData’s Password Recovery Toolkit to guess up to 900,000 passwords a second for encrypted Microsoft Office files. Encrypted PGP files allow about 900 password guesses per second.
Fifth, a weakness in the data protection system is something called the “Escrow Keybag”, which is a collection of keys necessary to decrypt every file on the device without requiring the user’s password. This was done to allow computers to sync with the iPhone without asking the user for the password.
This was a deliberate trade-off to enhance user experience. Apple’s rationale was that if the PC containing the escrow keybag was obtained, an attacker most likely already had the user’s important data anyway. For forensicators, this means that if a user’s computer is obtained along with the iPhone, it will be much easier to decrypt the user’s protected data.
Updated August 6, 2010: Elcomsoft has announced that its iPhone Password Breaker tool can recover iPhone keychains (probably the escrow keybag) from password-protected iPhone backups.
SummaryCurrently, data protection in iOS 4 is still limited. Apps must be updated to use data protection and currently only Mail does so. All other data can be easily obtained without the users password.
Even so, data protection in iOS 4 represents a significant improvement over encryption in iOS 3. It is clear that Apple is striving to iteratively improve security on the iPhone, which is a good thing.
In the meantime, it looks like forensicators won’t have to worry too much about getting the data they need off of an iPhone.